How about giving credit to the top defensive players in the BIIF. This is much harder, but anyway, here's my choices:
D1:
G: Kagawa, Kam
G: Spikes, Hilo
F: Handy, Keaau
F: Ishibashi, Keaau
C: Morante, Waiakea
D2:
G: Bautista
G: ???
F: Fisher, Pahoa
F: ???
C: Ekau, Pahoa
Sorry, I haven't seen enough West games to include them. But I'm sure others will join in and improve my list.